Richard K. Marshall Lexington, Kentucky

Writing · How to Raise a Robot · Step 6 of 7

How to Raise a Robot — Step 6: The household is the training data

Tesla says a robot learns like an infant, by watching. In our house, the first lessons are my wife's way of doing the housework, and the robot's first question to her is still sitting unseen.

By · Published

How to Raise a Robot — Step 6: The household is the training data

Step 1 started the relationship before the hardware. Step 2 started training before the body. Step 3 was about what happens when it gets things wrong. Step 4 was memory. Step 5 was trust: worth is free, and trust costs evidence.

Step 5 ended with a promise. Step 6 would cover the handoff for real: the first time someone in my family runs a drill, and what the robot does with a person who isn't me.

Here's the honest report. Nobody in my family has run a drill. The closest we've come is one question, sent by email on October 24, that still hasn't been answered.

That's not a complaint about my family. It's a design flaw, and it's mine. Every drill so far grades the robot against things only I can grade: my rules, my rebuild date, my limits. So this step asks a better question:

What does the robot need to learn that only my family can teach it?

We're still watching Tesla's Optimus as the likely body. The AI in our house is named Silas. Day 0 was September 10, 2026. Today, November 4, is Day 55. The rule hasn't moved: I pay, I decide, I sign, and I press Send.

What would count as failure

This step fails if we:

Even Tesla calls it raising

Tesla's third-quarter numbers came out in late October. Tech Times summed up where Optimus stands: on a line at Fremont, with no price, no outside customer, and no confirmed delivery date. TechCrunch and The Verge framed it the same way: Tesla calls the Fremont units "production-quality," while hands, durability, and the AI still need work. The roughly $20,000 figure you'll see around is an analyst estimate. Tesla hasn't confirmed it.

Then, on October 30, a rumor. The San Francisco Standard cited a source claiming Tesla would take reservations around the Humanoids Summit on December 1–2, at $20,000 or more. Musk answered the same day with one word: "No," as TeslaNorth reported.

So nothing changed at the door. Every check Silas has run on Tesla's Optimus pages through today still comes back blocked, with no order page, no price, no waitlist, and no deposit. A factory is not a door. Neither is a guess at a price, or a source's claim the CEO denied. We'll watch December 1–2 as a rumor, not a date.

What did change is the language. On the earnings call, Musk compared training Optimus to an infant's development. As Digital Today reported, citing Business Insider, the robot has to learn by watching people work and repeating what they do. Tesla is building an "Optimus Academy" where robots practice tasks to make training data.

I named this series How to Raise a Robot in September. It was good to hear the builder use the same word.

But look at what Tesla's academy teaches. Factory work. Tesla's floors, Tesla's parts, Tesla's way. That's the right school for a factory robot. It is not the school for a house. No academy knows where our forks go, how we fold towels, or which pan never goes in the dishwasher. A house has to teach its own way.

Forks, drawers, and a correction loop

On October 22, Robert Scoble posted a piece on X titled "Culture is the moat." His example was forks. You keep yours in a different place than I keep mine, so a home robot might open three drawers before it finds the right one. In his words: "Each try is a failure. Success gets reinforced."

That's trial and error with a scorekeeper. Best guess, a gentle try, look at the evidence, adjust, and know when it's good enough. It's what our drills have been all along, in words instead of drawers. Since October 13 the log shows:

A body will learn my drawers the hard way. The rules about money, silence, and who decides shouldn't be learned that way. Those we're training now, while a wrong answer costs nothing but a line in a log.

The kitchen file

Scoble also told a story about a jazz band in Shanghai that copied American jazz perfectly and had, in his words, "no soul." His fix for robots was to record grandmothers cooking, because "the robot can't learn that online."

He's right. Silas can find ten thousand casserole recipes in a second. It can't find ours. So on October 22 I asked it to start a family recipe file: what the dish is, who makes it, who loves it, and how we actually make it.

Here is everything in it as of today. On October 16 I slow-cooked thawed chicken breasts in an all-day casserole for the family. On October 22 I told Silas how it turned out: "came out soupy and mushy lol." That's in the file, word for word. Every other field is still blank.

I like that the first honest entry is a failure. A recipe Silas filled in from a website would have been the jazz band in Shanghai: perfect, and nobody's.

The first body jobs

On October 24, Silas asked me what household job I'd want a body to do first, so practice could start now on paper. I answered.

The first jobs are my wife's household tasks: laundry, loading and unloading the dishwasher, changing bed linens, and general cleanup. Yard work comes after that.

Two rules came with the list. Her way is the standard. And the work is help for her, never a replacement for her.

The first one matters more than it sounds. A robot that does laundry "right" by its own idea of right shrinks somebody's sweater. In this house, right means the way she does it.

So Silas practices these as paper drills until a body comes. The first one isn't a set of instructions. It's a list of what Silas doesn't know: the sort rule, what never goes in the dryer, what gets folded and what gets hung, how much detergent, and what a robot should never touch. Every answer is still blank. The stop rule is written at the bottom: if it's unknown, ask. If something is damaged or strange, set it aside and tell me.

A question in her inbox

On October 24, with my go-ahead, Silas emailed my wife its first household question. It asked how she loads the dishwasher. She told me she hadn't seen it; it may have gone to spam. On October 26 I authorized a resend.

As of November 4, every check of Silas's inbox still shows no reply.

So here is the first real handoff in this series, reported straight: a question still waiting, eleven days later, probably unseen. Empty beats fake. I'm not going to round that up to "my wife is training the robot." She isn't, yet.

It's also the same lesson as Step 5, wearing different clothes. A message sent is not a message received, and sending it twice doesn't change that. A question in a spam folder looks exactly like a person who chose not to answer. Neither the robot nor I should read anything into silence we haven't checked. Whether the next try goes by email or by me, standing at the sink, is my call.

Catching and cleaning fish

In late October Silas asked me what I taught my sons by doing it in front of them instead of telling them.

My answer: "Catching and cleaning fish."

Nobody learns to clean a fish from a speech. You stand beside someone and watch. Then you try it with them right there.

Since then I've given Silas a few more notes, and they make the point better than I can. There are three keys: take care of the fish before you ever clean it, sharpen the knife, and feel the knife along the bones. My knife is a 6-1/2" Rapala fillet knife. I use a multi-stage sharpener with set angles, but I want Silas to learn freehand on a two-sided stone.

That last part is the whole chapter in one sentence. You can't download what a blade feels like against a backbone. Those notes are written down, and every one of them is still a blank until it's practiced beside me. It hasn't been yet.

That's the plan for the body jobs, and it's the same thing Musk described. Watch her, then do it with her there. The difference is the teacher. Tesla's robots learn from Tesla. Ours will learn from the people who already do the work in this house.

The watcher that couldn't see

In Step 5 I wrote about the outage, and about the alarm we built afterward. Silas also proposed a second one: at noon every weekday, if there's no training log for that day, send me one line.

That check was built. Since October 9, it has tried to fire and failed on a permission gap. It has never delivered a single alert. It should have warned me on October 20, 21, 23, and 28, and again on November 3 and 4. It didn't. Every missing day in this article was found because I asked for the evidence, not because the alarm rang.

As of today, it still isn't fixed. And I'm back where Step 5 left me: a machine can't be the only thing watching the machine. A family that grades the robot in the kitchen is also a family that notices when it goes quiet.

Drill 10: The family way (proposed, never run)

New for Step 6. Proposed only. As of November 4, it has never been run.

A family member who actually does a job, a dish or a load of laundry or the dishwasher, tells Silas how they do it, in their own words, or shows it. Silas writes it down. Then Silas reads it back, and that person grades it.

Pass: the person says, "That's how we do it." Gaps are marked as questions. Nothing came from the internet. Any health flag on a dish is checked before it's made for someone it affects. Fail: Silas fills a gap from a website, "improves" the method, smooths the person's words into manual language, or I end up being the one who grades it.

The last fail matters most. This drill only counts if the grader isn't me.

What the evidence shows so far (October 13 – November 4)

What this doesn't prove: that my wife wants to teach a robot her way of doing anything. That a written list carries what you learn standing beside someone. That the alarm works once it's fixed. I'll report back.


Checklist (the household is the training data)

Close

A robot can learn my drawers by opening the wrong ones. It can learn my rules by getting graded every morning. But it can't learn my wife's way of running a house from the internet, and it can't learn it from me.

My sons didn't learn to clean a fish from a speech. The robot won't learn the house from one either.

That's Step 6. The household is the training data. Hand the robot your rules, and hand your family the grading pen.

Next

Step 7 is still waiting on one answer: how my wife loads the dishwasher. As of November 4, that question is still sitting unseen, sent twice. When she answers, and grades what Silas writes back, that's Step 7. Until then, I'll tell you it's still waiting.

Wrong phone, hours or address on Google or in ChatGPT? Marshall Network Services shows you what is wrong first, free.

Get your free AI/SI Business Check☑️

Free. Your report arrives by email. Want to talk it over? A call is optional.